People with the best intentions are still subject to improper execution (just ask Jules). Sometimes the “good guys” seem to have this fixation with getting some magic number of signatures, which will then magically produce the solution to their goal. Unfortunately their numeros magicos appear to be arbitrary and bear no signifigance to actually producing change. I will provide a pair of examples.
I understand that Amnesty International is working with the best possible intentions, but I fear that their methods are terribly pointless. I bought their Instant Karma double CD because the artists and songs were outstanding, and now I’m on their mailing list.
They want to tear down Guantanamo Bay. Great, I agree that the stuff going down there goes against everything America stands for (ie. freedom, justice), but I don’t think yet another petition is going to actually close it down. If they can get 500,000 signatures then “we’ll have the power and strength needed to tear down the real Guantanamo Bay.”
Umm, I hate to burst your bubble – it’s a really wonderful bubble, truly – but no, you won’t. There are over 300 million American citizens, and over 60% of them oppose the war in Iraq. Have 500,000 of them signed petitions to withdraw the troops? I don’t know, but the important part of petitions is enlightening the decision makers about what the masses desire. Over 200 million people want a thing, and it ain’t even close to being done.
Seriously, do you believe collecting names electronically will force the military to close down a (to them) necessary military installation? Did you notice the uses of the word ‘military’ in that sentence? If there is one thing the military has never done, and must never do, is listen to public opinion.
The second magic number comes from your favorite group of wussies, the Democrats, combatting W.’s veto of the SCHIP cash. This example is just absurd, whether you agree with the politics or not.
Here’s the quote from Governor Dean’s camp: “over 90,000 letters were sent, with every single member of Congress getting at least one.” That’s a real number, so here’s the magic number: “let’s get to 125,000 letters by the end of the day. Congress can’t ignore 125,000 letters from ordinary Americans demanding health care coverage for children.”
Why, exactly, is that? See the above point on the Iraq war. They can, and they are ignoring those letters. Want proof? You, Gov. Dean, noted that they have ignored 90,000 letters, so what exactly is it about those last 35,000 letters that is going to cross the tipping point? Better stationary?
Well intentioned? Most probably! Arbitrary? Most definitely!
Update: Not to keep picking on Amnesty, but their “Amnesty Wireless” website contains an image with this text: “Last spring, Amnesty Wireless members organized to call for the immediate closure of the cruel and inhuman prison at Guantanamo Bay.” Why are they bragging about doing something that didn’t get anything done? Yesterday I screamed at all the stupid drivers sharing the road with me and they didn’t get any better, maybe I could use that to start a wireless company.